Celebrity tattles are talking about The View cast-away Star Jones’ appearance at the Nikki Beach Nightclub Party on January 27. Star’s Double D batteries have planted speculation that the former daytime talk show host has undergone another round of plastic surgery.

Beverly Hills Dr. Renato Calabria, who hasn’t treated Star, thinks that her changing shape isn’t from new breast implants, but rather due to the natural effects of gravity on the old ones. “It happens all the time: After the surgery, the skin is nice and tight, but over time it relaxes and drops,” he says, “especially if someone gains weight.”