Sibiling Stallionaires Real and Chance — who first invaded our TV screens when they dueled for the heart of reality TV villainess New York before appearing in the spinoff series Real Chance of Love — are back! This time, the guys are set to traverse the wilderness in search of nature’s most legendary creatures — including The Mega Shark, Big Foot, Hogzilla, The Chupacabrah).

WTF?! Each week they learn the tales of each quarry from locals and experts before embarking on their adventures to find the legends among us. Er — They couldn’t have at least cast these two in another dating show?

Real & Chance: The Legend Hunters premieres Sunday, Sept. 19 @ 9PM ET/PT.